Gains as a percentage?

[incogneeetoe Moderator Member of the Month Sept 2017*Special Appreciated Moderator Nov. 2021* PEGym Hero Find all posts View Profile Close incogneeetoe]

It is an interesting idea to look at percentage for gains, but the flaw is that the calculation here is just on length, and does not take into account girth.

I did by length alone and I gained 22%.
But when girth is taken in (via volume calculated over at calcSD) I have gained 45%

[yebber Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close yebber]

It is an interesting idea to look at percentage for gains, but the flaw is that the calculation here is just on length, and does not take into account girth.

I did by length alone and I gained 22%.
But when girth is taken in (via volume calculated over at calcSD) I have gained 45%

Agreed that's exactly what I thought when I saw it. The real size increase is the volumetric increase. The other two dimensional values are, in practice, less irrelevant.

[Phoenix7672 Senior Member Member of the Month Oct 2015 Find all posts View Profile Close Phoenix7672]

Around 15% for me...6.8" to 8"