Girth....or is it Volume?

[BMot Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close BMot]

Well, I've seen from a lot of posts that women tend to prefer girth over length but I've started to wonder that when people claim that girth is the best, they actually mean volume.

I would have thought that volume would give a greater sense of being full, rather than the actual girth itself. For example, a guy may have a 6" girth, but only a 1" length (yeah, I know, very unlikely but bear with me). That size isn't going to give a feeling of fullness, but of being stretched. The same with a guy with a 7" length, but 1" girth (wow, these example guys are unlucky!).

Feel free is disagree at any point, I'm only throwing my thoughts out there.

Now, a guy with a 6 x 5 penis would have a volume of 195. Add an extra inch to that length and he would have a volume of 228. However, if you add an extra inch to the girth, rather than the length the volume shoots up to 279 - I'm sure many of you already know this and I'm preaching to the converted, but hey.

Therefore, my theory is that girth is claimed to be the best of the two, as it gives a greater volume increase than length does, but it's actually the volume that 'really' matters.

Discuss away, my friends.

[Fli-Fisher Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close Fli-Fisher]

Sounds logical... Instead of feeling fuller just at the back it is now throughout.

[Batwoman Moderator ReservePEGym Hero Find all posts View Profile Close Batwoman]

Good question! In my opinion, I would say that the three measures you mentioned are important in this order (most important to least important):
(1) girth
(2) volume
(3) length
Girth truly is most important because many of the nerves that give us girls lots of sensations and pleasure during penetration are associated with the vaginal opening. The stretching of that opening is one of the primary things we feel. Next, volume is important because yes, that full feeling is great, and important. Length - exactly how deep he goes - is probably the least important of the three items. Yes, we like length..... but fullness and girth are where the main sensations are. And between volume and girth, I think girth is most important. Does that make sense?

[Pegasus AdministratorPE Gym EditorPEGym Hero ☺ Admin of the Month Mar 2015 Find all posts View Profile Close Pegasus]

Said it before I think it depends on the girl.

[Batwoman Moderator ReservePEGym Hero Find all posts View Profile Close Batwoman]

Said it before I think it depends on the girl.

Very true. I was only expressing my own opinions on the matter!

[Batwoman Moderator ReservePEGym Hero Find all posts View Profile Close Batwoman]

However, I should probably emend even my own opinions. I ranked length last in terms of what it contributes to female sensations..... but I need to add some caveats.
First, really great length (7.5" and up, I would guess) may be a different matter, since then the female "A-spot" might come in to play. See this thread on that topic: https://www.pegym.com/forums/womans-...0891-spot.html
Also, length is not just important in how deep a guy can get. Length can also make some really fun positions work better. From that perspective, length is definitely important! Anyway, I still think I ranked girth, volume, and length roughly in the order that they matter overall but it is a complicated thing.

[Pegasus AdministratorPE Gym EditorPEGym Hero ☺ Admin of the Month Mar 2015 Find all posts View Profile Close Pegasus]

There may be something there bmot but it's hard to get clarity with a question like this. Batwoman has done her best but as she says it's a complicated thing and would vary person to person .

[doupdoupdoup Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close doupdoupdoup]

OP, I think that is just oversimplifying things or making things too complicated. "Length and girth" is a better way to think about it. Unless you want to start thinking in calculus formulas. I'm sure volume is a factor, but it's much easier just to leave that as something to think about in the back of the head.

I think if you are in the optimum range of girth and length, then volume becomes the thing that is stimulating in those moments of deep penetration, but if you are within that range of girth and length, it does not matter anyway.

But still it would be funny if we started to do volume tests.

[Pegasus AdministratorPE Gym EditorPEGym Hero ☺ Admin of the Month Mar 2015 Find all posts View Profile Close Pegasus]

Actually many members do measure volume and several sites will calculate it for you.

[Gel King Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close Gel King]

I haven't been this frustrated calculating volume since elementary school.. my girth varies, my penis is not a perfect cylinder, and my glans are oddly shaped =/ *Peaks at seatmate for the answer*