Here's me toying with your mind

[pe4life2 Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close pe4life2]

To get the right answer it doesn't matter which angel is guarding heaven and which is guarding hell.

Ok. I've heard the version that the honest one is guarding heaven and the lying one is guarding hell. In that case you would ask whichever guard "What's my name?" or some personal question or easy question like 1+1. If the guard you ask answers it correct you go through that, but if they answer it wrong you go through the other door. I guess that one's way easier than your version haha. I'm stumped.

[Toadstool Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close Toadstool]

Ok. I've heard the version that the honest one is guarding heaven and the lying one is guarding hell. In that case you would ask whichever guard "What's my name?" or some personal question or easy question like 1+1. If the guard you ask answers it correct you go through that, but if they answer it wrong you go through the other door. I guess that one's way easier than your version haha. I'm stumped.

lol no it doesn't work that way. You can ask only one question.
There's no one guarding a door. You're in a room with two doors. To help you make your decision are two guys in that room. No guards, no angels, no demons. LOL let's keep it simple.

[pe4life2 Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close pe4life2]

lol no it doesn't work that way. You can ask only one question.
There's no one guarding a door. You're in a room with two doors. To help you make your decision are two guys in that room. No guards, no angels, no demons. LOL let's keep it simple.

Lol I was referring to imac's version (below) since I've heard one similar to his. Nevertheless, I'm totally wrong haha.

The version I heard went something like this,

You've just died and before you are two doors, one leading to heaven one leading to hell,
Guarding each door is an angel, one is the angel of truth and will always tell the truth and the other is the angel of lies and will alway lie.

You don't know which angel is which only the angels know which one lies and which tells the truth. Only the angels know which door they guard.

You can only ask one question, how do you find the door that leads to heaven?

[TheSperminator Member of the Month Oct 12 Find all posts View Profile Close TheSperminator]

To the ones asking the question. Did you come up with the answer on your own?

[imac Retired Moderator Member of the Month Nov 12PEGym Hero Find all posts View Profile Close imac]

Toodstool's and my version is pretty much the same. The answers are slightly different but the logic you use to arrive at the answer is the same.

[Toadstool Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close Toadstool]

To the ones asking the question. Did you come up with the answer on your own?

i did, yes.

[imac Retired Moderator Member of the Month Nov 12PEGym Hero Find all posts View Profile Close imac]

To the ones asking the question. Did you come up with the answer on your own?

Yep.

[Jm123 Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close Jm123]

You ask one of them which door the other guy would say they came into the room from. You then take the other door.

[imac Retired Moderator Member of the Month Nov 12PEGym Hero Find all posts View Profile Close imac]

You ask one of them which door the other guy would say they came into the room from. You then take the other door.

Are you talking about Toadstool's version?

[TheSperminator Member of the Month Oct 12 Find all posts View Profile Close TheSperminator]

I GOT IT!

You just ask "is this the door to hell?"

[Nachos87 Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close Nachos87]

"Would I be right to assume, that you'd tell me this door (points at the door) will lead me to my freedom?"

Is all I could figure out. They will both say yes or no. You go through if it's YES and go through the other one if it's a NO.

So I changed my question in order for better explanation. I'm not sure what's the issue with this.

If I point at the freedom door and asked this question to the truthful one:
1) He would indeed tell me that this door are Freedom door, if I asked him about it. But that's not his verbal answer, because that's not what I'm asking.
2) That means that my assumption is right.
3) He will then proceed to say: "YES, your assumption is right."

If I point at the freedom door and asked this question to the lieing one:
1) He would tell me that this door are Death door, if I asked him about it. But that's not his verbal answer, because that's not what I'm asking.
2) That means that my assumption is wrong. He wouldn't tell me that this door are Freedom door.
3) He will then proceed to say: "YES, your assumption is right." because he can't tell me that I'm wrong, he is a liar after all.

Same goes for the other door. They will both say YES for the Freedom door and they will both say NO for the Death door.
I understand that this question might be a bit complicated but it will let him be free. So I demand cookies :P

[imac Retired Moderator Member of the Month Nov 12PEGym Hero Find all posts View Profile Close imac]

I GOT IT!

You just ask "is this the door to hell?"

How would that let you know which door to go through.

[TheSperminator Member of the Month Oct 12 Find all posts View Profile Close TheSperminator]

I GOT IT!

You just ask "is this the door to hell?"

Wait, I think I'm still stuck here. Does the liar lie to make you choose the bad door? or does he always lie no matter what?

[Jm123 Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close Jm123]

Are you talking about Toodstool's version?

Both versions. You ask one of them which door the other guy or angel would say they came into the room/ purgatory from. You then take the other door.

[Toadstool Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close Toadstool]

If you go up to the liar and point to the death door
You ask him, Would I be right to assume that this door leads to my freedom?

your assumption is that the door you're pointing to is freedom, when it is in fact the death door.
The liar would say, yes you would be right in that assumption. And then you would walk to your death.