Ladies, if you were a man, what size.....

[ThinJohnny Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close ThinJohnny]

I'm glad the ladies were honest. And I'm just happy they didn't say 10 X 7

It's what they would want, and maybe even what they ideally would want in a man, but neither of them said they wouldn't consider being with a man with smaller stats. They have both said the opposite in many threads on here.

[NP97 Retired ModeratorPEGym Hero Find all posts View Profile Close NP97]

i didn't say its what i prefer ..i said its what i would choose if i was a guy.. small difference but a big difference...
it doesn't matter what we said .. i could have said i would have a 4.5" x 5 and i would have been accused of lying, and still had people feeling like they didn't match up ..
i would want an average size cock .. i went the bigger end of average.. because if i was a man i would be navigating life in a mans world, having to deal with other men... and i am the first to admit i am not great at judging girth just by sight, because i never gave it much thought before i came here.

I think many people just forgot the point. Not what size you need to please a woman... if you were a MAN what size would you WANT to BE. With most of us striving to be at least 7x5.5 that seems to be a fair answer.
Like I said, my girlfriend said 6". Didn't ask her what she thought about girth but she thinks five is pretty thick. So.... whatever. Doesn't matter.

Just keep this puppy on topic because it's kinda funny and interesting.

[aidan784 Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close aidan784]

I had some thoughts about this thread and Skeptic sort of hit on it. When you first saw this thread did you picture yourself as a man with a penis?

It seems both of you thought of the penis as its own thing with its own dimensions, as opposed to comparing it to the rest of your body. We know several guys have ended up here because of perception, whether it be large hands, large body/height, fat pad etc.

I think it's better that you considered just the penis dimensions, but what height do you picture yourself? Should we assume good shape? A 0.5" fat pad?
I agree with somebodyelse, this could be a good topic.

As for the 'surely cock size matters because women talk about it', that's just society, I would like to place some blame on porn, that's just me.
But then when I think about it, I haven't heard much discussion from girls talking about penis size. Other than a girl when I was in school (we would have been 15 I think), saying she'd had an 8 incher and some of the girls got a bit excited, but most of them were virgins so you know...

But then maybe that talk is just kept private.

[hunglet Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close hunglet]

To be fair to the guys getting upset. If I went to a forum like thisNatural Breast Enhancement Forums !

HOLY CRAP!! Natural breast enchancement works? I know some girls would be very happy to know, but I'm not sure how I would approach them on that, I'd rather stay shut, unless the girl is my GF.

[wind chill Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close wind chill]

Interesting thought!
I'd want to be 7.0" BPEL x 5.5" EG.... flaccid would be irrelevant (just not very interesting to me).... circumcised (though if I lived outside the USA, I might feel differently about that)....

what about nbpel?

[Total_Honesty Banned Find all posts View Profile Close Total_Honesty]

Total honesty time again:

I don't think women would know what to do with one if they only had it for one day. What about the scrotum and testicles. How would a woman react if she get hit there? Hell, would any of us guys know how to handle a vagina for a day, either? I think most of yall would faint or panic if it started to bleed.

Just being honest. That's all I can be.

[wind chill Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close wind chill]

HOLY CRAP!! Natural breast enchancement works? I know some girls would be very happy to know, but I'm not sure how I would approach them on that, I'd rather stay shut, unless the girl is my GF.

wow.I never knew this.
I bet it's like PE,takes a lot of time to see good results.

[somebodyelse Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close somebodyelse]

Total honesty time again:

I don't think women would know what to do with one if they only had it for one day. What about the scrotum and testicles. How would a woman react if she get hit there? Hell, would any of us guys know how to handle a vagina for a day, either? I think most of yall would faint or panic if it started to bleed.

Just being honest. That's all I can be.

I know I wouldn't want it... I used to think "what it would be like to have one" just for a day, I'd give it a test drive...

If I had to chose, I would keep the peen. The Vagina is such a high maintenance tool. I read in some articles that too much SEX can cause an imbalance in the pH levels in the vagina and produce an odor. WTF! That would suck! I admire women for putting up with that thing. I love to play with them, love to look at them. Love the way a healthy one tastes and smells... i even like the popping sound it makes when you're working her G-spot.... AHHH

If i had one, I'd play with it for a while... try to see what all the parts did... but like i said, holy crap, i would only want to be test driving it, not owning it for the rest of my life! Takes a special kind of species to deal with that.

[MrBigDick Retired ModeratorPEGym Hero Find all posts View Profile Close MrBigDick]

I know I wouldn't want it... I used to think "what it would be like to have one" just for a day, I'd give it a test drive...

If I had to chose, I would keep the peen. The Vagina is such a high maintenance tool. I read in some articles that too much SEX can cause an imbalance in the pH levels in the vagina and produce an odor. WTF! That would suck! I admire women for putting up with that thing. I love to play with them, love to look at them. Love the way a healthy one tastes and smells... i even like the popping sound it makes when you're working her G-spot.... AHHH

If i had one, I'd play with it for a while... try to see what all the parts did... but like i said, holy crap, i would only want to be test driving it, not owning it for the rest of my life! Takes a special kind of species to deal with that.

Very true and I concur with you, but, if that's what you were born with and hence all you know how to deal with.......

[closeed258 Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close closeed258]

I'm stealing this question from another site because the answers over there are so interesting and revealing. So to turn the tables a bit, ladies, if you were to be turned into a man on a date certain, with all atributes being ideal and you could be hung any way you wanted, what size would you choose, flaccid and erect, circumcised or not, grower or shower? Also, what's the first thing you would do?

Since I'm not a woman I can't answer this question, but I can answer the reverse question!!!

I would have a minge that is 4.5" circumference with smallish pink flaps shaved and I would finger myself all day and get licked out then when I turn back to a man I would know exactly how I liked to fingered and licked and do that to the ladies!!

[amiok Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close amiok]

Nah TT, most of the reasonable guys on the forum know that you guys were just answering the questions. Your answers are no different from what guys do want, and you're catching some shit from it from people like amiok. Everybody else realizes how ridiculous his posts are, even if he doesn't.

Never attacked them.

I was never like "oh the ladies would want a big dick if they were guys" and then ranted about that. All I said was that a woman could get off from your ability even if you're small, but she'd still wish you were bigger WITH those skills. Not sure how I got perceived as attacking them because I just reread my posts and any of them that could be perceived as purposely confrontational were not directed at them.

I did get a bit ridiculous with my little side convo with Captain Dallas but eh that's another story.

[funflyer Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close funflyer]

Total honesty time again:

I don't think women would know what to do with one if they only had it for one day. What about the scrotum and testicles. How would a woman react if she get hit there? Hell, would any of us guys know how to handle a vagina for a day, either? I think most of yall would faint or panic if it started to bleed.

Just being honest. That's all I can be.

If I had a vagina for a day I would be a slut. I would spend the morning fingering it and getting it licked and sucked so I'd know just the right ways then I'd experience as much sex with different size penises as I could till I found out which size was best. Then I think I would spend the rest of the day just enjoying the knowledge my dick will be back tomorrow.

[Closed039 Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close Closed039]

Never attacked them.

I was never like "oh the ladies would want a big dick if they were guys" and then ranted about that. All I said was that a woman could get off from your ability even if you're small, but she'd still wish you were bigger WITH those skills. Not sure how I got perceived as attacking them because I just reread my posts and any of them that could be perceived as purposely confrontational were not directed at them.

I did get a bit ridiculous with my little side convo with Captain Dallas but eh that's another story.

I never said you attacked them. I'm assuming you are suggesting that by quoting what I said. Please re-read my post, carefully this time. What I did say is that you gave the women shit about answering the OPs question, which you did, because of your own insecurity or whatever. Normally I would just ignore this but you literally hijacked the thread and made the women less likely to respond to future questions.

[mrmark Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close mrmark]

Just noticed this thread,i think some peole may have mis read it as what size dick to the women on hear prefer as oppossed to if you were a man for a day what size dick would you like to have.Why do these threads that even mention the word size in it bring out insecurities in some people.If you ask a question then expect an answer and just because it is not what you would like to hear does not mean there is something wrong with the other person!.So honest question = honest answer.Please do not attack the ladies just because they answered a question,they are very useful and knowlegable and its nice to have them around to interact with us and at the end of the day they are just trying to help.So next time something offends you just do not read it or better still grow the fuck up.I would like an 8 inch dick but im not going to lose sleep just because i have not got it.

[Pirate Retired AdministratorPEGym Hero Find all posts View Profile Close Pirate]

I think the breast size analogy is a pretty good one. If this site was dedicated to breast enhancement, and the thread question was: What size boobs would you guys pick if you were a woman and could choose your breast size?
My answer would probably be C cup: plenty of cleavage but not enough to cause back pain or interfere with athletics. And that answer would likely bring out the insecurities in a lot of women with breasts smaller than C even though I have not said anything about the breast sizes that I might prefer on a partner. In fact, I have never met a breast that I didn't enjoy thoroughly, and I have never found myself thinking "Gee, I wish her boobs were bigger!" while having sex. Plus, I have never failed to cum because her breasts were too small (or too large.)
So, does breast size matter to me? Yes, it is important that her breasts have a size (or two) but it doesn't matter to me much what that size is.