What do you guys think is thick?

[Phoenix7672 Senior Member Member of the Month Oct 2015 Find all posts View Profile Close Phoenix7672]

below 4.5 is thin
4.5-5.25 is average
5.25-5.5 is big
5.5 and above is huge, and probably not even worth it tbh.

Personally I'd say it would be more like:

Below 5" is thin/low average
5"-5.25" is high average
5.5"-5.75" is big
5.75"-6" is borderline huge (similar to say, around 8" length)
6"-6.5" is huge
Above 6.5" is massive and too big for a number of girls out there

Above is based on my own views and size though, with very limited experience (so yours are likely closer to reality than mine).

[Fishy Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close Fishy]

I'd go for a girth where you can't quite make your fingers touch if you hold your erection in an 'OK' grip. For me this would be around the 6 inch mark

You are probably right. But it depends on your hands size. I have a small hands, so i cant do squeezes properly

[jockinthebox Retired Moderator Member of the Month May 2015PEGym Hero Find all posts View Profile Close jockinthebox]

why are you making girls the top priority? do PE for you, no to please a defined group of women. I'm 6`, I have problems because of it and I can't give two fucks, I will keep the growing on.
edit: you have guys like jockinthebox that are saying "i dont want more girth", but they don't want it because it causes problems to them (no dp, having to use lube, whatv). This is what I'm saying, do it for yourself on the first place!Of course, on sex related things you'll want to take your partners into account, but always that it doesn't sets you back.

This thread started 8 months ago, and I'm still "active", just wearing my PF daily 11+ hours now. I do no other PE. My goals have been accomplished (BPEL 7.75) & MEG (5.75"+) BEG (6+"), so I'm maintaining; however, if I get to 8" BPEL WITHOUT my flaccid growing more (now 6.25+" X 5.25+"), I'd be OK with it. I can control how deeply I penetrate, but NOT the stretch of my GF from my girth. I enjoy PE, but when it becomes a challenge for your partner oral, vaginal, or certainly anal. then guys need to reconsider, plus there are other personal factors to be aware of...

I don't look forward to the summer months, when it's hot as hell and my balls stick to my legs and my penis sticks to my balls, my flaccid sweats so much my crotch stays wet all day, and I have to make body powder & jock itch treatments a part of my daily routine. <THAT has been a part of my life since I was a boy...there's just MORE area to treat (and sweat / itch) now! Just be careful and give some thought to your goals guys...that's all I'm sayin'.

[Woah Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close Woah]

thick
THik/
adjective

• 1.
  with opposite sides or surfaces that are a great or relatively great distance apart.
  
• 2.
  made up of a large number of things or people close together.
  [COLOR=#878787 !important]"his hair was long and thick"[/COLOR]
  

  synonyms:

  plentiful, abundant, profuse, luxuriant, bushy, rich, riotous, exuberant;More

noun

• 1.
  the busiest or most crowded part of something; the middle of something.
  [COLOR=#878787 !important]"the thick of battle"[/COLOR]
  

  synonyms:

  midst, center, hub, middle, core, heart"in the thick of the crisis"

adverb

• 1.
  in or with deep, dense, or heavy mass.
  
  

[dukenukem8 Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close dukenukem8]

Personally I'd say it would be more like:

Below 5" is thin/low average
5"-5.25" is high average
5.5"-5.75" is big
5.75"-6" is borderline huge (similar to say, around 8" length)
6"-6.5" is huge
Above 6.5" is massive and too big for a number of girls out there

Above is based on my own views and size though, with very limited experience (so yours are likely closer to reality than mine).

I'm bi, and have experience with women/men reacting to my size, and me reacting to other men's size. Also, the many studies that have been done aren't really lying, from personal experience. They are accurate for the most part. I feel as if this contorted perception of what is normal based on the media's standpoint, has convinced people that big is only average. Everyone needs to stop with that, I was convinced of it also, it's liberating to be over it.
I'd say it follows along with the studies alot more than you believe.
Thin 4.6 and under
Average 4.7-5.1
Big 5.2-5.5 (tight in a tp roll)
Huge 5.6-6
Massive 6.1+

Based on my experience, I would tend to see a good chunk of guys probably 1/4-1/2 inch thinner than me. It seems quite normal. If I had to give a number for big, I'd say maybe 1-3 guys out of 10 would be around the same girth. For the others probably 1 in 20 and 50.
I always had them beat in length though

[Phoenix7672 Senior Member Member of the Month Oct 2015 Find all posts View Profile Close Phoenix7672]

I'm bi, and have experience with women/men reacting to my size, and me reacting to other men's size. Also, the many studies that have been done aren't really lying, from personal experience. They are accurate for the most part. I feel as if this contorted perception of what is normal based on the media's standpoint, has convinced people that big is only average. Everyone needs to stop with that, I was convinced of it also, it's liberating to be over it.
I'd say it follows along with the studies alot more than you believe.
Thin 4.6 and under
Average 4.7-5.1
Big 5.2-5.5 (tight in a tp roll)
Huge 5.6-6
Massive 6.1+

Based on my experience, I would tend to see a good chunk of guys probably 1/4-1/2 inch thinner than me. It seems quite normal. If I had to give a number for big, I'd say maybe 1-3 guys out of 10 would be around the same girth. For the others probably 1 in 20 and 50.
I always had them beat in length though

Well only experience I have with penises are my own and what I try to interpret from porn, so your views are more valid than mine on what's out there lol. I definitely want to think of being 5" or just above as 'big', but it just doesn't look it to me, even though in other ways I know it must be to some degree (eg. posts like yours, the fact I much prefer large condoms over normal, the fact only the first 1/4 or less can fit in a TP roll, etc).

[rbi99 Retired Moderator Member of the Month Nov 2017PEGym Hero Find all posts View Profile Close rbi99]

For us married guys or guys with very steady girlfriends, the definition of thick is that point where any more girth is problematic. I have a lot of girth and my wife is not large in stature, but she can handle me easily both orally and vaginally. I have always been thicker than average so we have never attempted anal. You single guys have to find your own definition!!!

[Praetorian Senior Member Member of the Month Feb 2016 Find all posts View Profile Close Praetorian]

My forearm and the sledgehammer on the end that is called a fist is pretty thick....

[PurpleOnes Senior Member Member of the Month June 2014PEGym Hero Find all posts View Profile Close PurpleOnes]

I would call thick something in the range of 6.3 to 7.5 inches.

That's in my head but for a girl thick probably means much less.

[GTO Retired ModeratorPEGym EditorPEGym Hero Find all posts View Profile Close GTO]

I'm bi, and have experience with women/men reacting to my size, and me reacting to other men's size. Also, the many studies that have been done aren't really lying, from personal experience. They are accurate for the most part. I feel as if this contorted perception of what is normal based on the media's standpoint, has convinced people that big is only average. Everyone needs to stop with that, I was convinced of it also, it's liberating to be over it.
I'd say it follows along with the studies alot more than you believe.
Thin 4.6 and under
Average 4.7-5.1
Big 5.2-5.5 (tight in a tp roll)
Huge 5.6-6
Massive 6.1+

Based on my experience, I would tend to see a good chunk of guys probably 1/4-1/2 inch thinner than me. It seems quite normal. If I had to give a number for big, I'd say maybe 1-3 guys out of 10 would be around the same girth. For the others probably 1 in 20 and 50.
I always had them beat in length though

Since you are looking at it literally from both sides of the spectrum, I would have to concede that your points are a lot more valid than most. But on your scale where you have anything over 6" being "massive," I just have a hard time wrapping my head around that one. Having been called "very thick" or "extremely thick" from every woman I've been with, I fall into the trap of only having dealt with my own and having my own sense of size. I'm still looking for a little more than what I have.

[dukenukem8 Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close dukenukem8]

Since you are looking at it literally from both sides of the spectrum, I would have to concede that your points are a lot more valid than most. But on your scale where you have anything over 6" being "massive," I just have a hard time wrapping my head around that one. Having been called "very thick" or "extremely thick" from every woman I've been with, I fall into the trap of only having dealt with my own and having my own sense of size. I'm still looking for a little more than what I have.

Yeah, being on the other end, you notice how big say a 5.2-5.5 girth is. It's all perspective. Anything in the 6 inch girth range is massive. What is it like the 99 percentile? Of course it doesn't seem like it to us though when this entire forum is about getting bigger than average and big, also when there are 1 in 10,000 guys out there with a 7 inch girth. You need to look at the standard deviation that's where you find your answers. It usually ranges about about 1 inch from the average of 4.5. So the higher you are in that deviation, the closer you are to being able to confirm your size is big.

I am 5.3 ish. If the deviation is 1 inch. That means 90% would tend to fall in the 4.5-5.5 range. Although, considering the average set number, that means we can assume most in that entire group would range from 4.5-4.8 or something like that. So we can say of that 90%, about 65% fall into that 4.5 to 4.8 range. So of the total actual population, you're looking at about roughly 60ish% that are in that range. That means even if you are in that deviation, the higher you go from 4.8, the higher you are placed because of the average. So of the remaining 25% in the deviation, I'd be placed into the 85th percentile, along with the others ranging in the higher 80's. Then, all of the naturally thicker guys are the automatic 10%. That means, odd are, anybody with a 5.6-6+ are probably going to be the thickest a person has been with. That's how I conclude it's massive. I hope this made sense, I'm writing this late and my numbers are kind of jumbled.

Besides all of that. The 6 feels massive. Really gives you a stretch, which isn't always the best thing to be honest. That depends on the girl (or guy). That's why I'm going for 5 3/4
But yeah, you're massive when it comes to girth, like an 8 inch length is considered massive in my book, using the same logic.
Sorry if all of that was confusing. Lol.

[Biscut Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close Biscut]

It's all about the perspective.

If a girl is a virgin 4.3" would be the biggest thing ever.
If the girl has had 10 partners probably not.

For the original question 5.5"+ is big

I agree, what ever you do do it for you not her. Gain a 1/4" in girth and know you are the girthiest you have ever been and walk tall.

[akaTrex Senior Member Member of the Month Jan 2016 Find all posts View Profile Close akaTrex]

Anything above 6.0!

My Bride has started to complain once I surpassed 6.25 EG !

Silicone Lube is a Must NOW!

[Candola Member Find all posts View Profile Close Candola]

Anything above 5.5" for me

[DaddyDick Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close DaddyDick]

5 to 5.5 for me. More than that and you better be quick. 6+ and you might just be getting head and a hand job.

Length can be worked with, but thickness is...well if it hurts it hurts.