Women: How much girth is too much?

[heretohelp Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close heretohelp]

Thanks for responding, heretohelp? Yes, I meant the first time having sex ever.

It varies from woman to woman but I have a pretty high pain threshold and that first time was a killer without a lot of thickness. Just be understanding if she's in a lot of pain, go very, very slowly (it's not like ripping a band aid off no matter what anybody says) and try to make her as comfortable as possible.

[Thick_Unit Banned Find all posts View Profile Close Thick_Unit]

Doublelongdaddy although believed to be pretty full of shit in his own size claims and photoshopping, believes that both diesel and shorty mac had sickle cell anemia causing hypoxia induced megalophallus which you can google about and gives good explanation for the true freaks of nature of dick girth .. and I agree, because if you look at diesel's dick, the top of his dick is much MUCH thinner than the middle and below, consistent of what you'd see in megalophallus "sufferers" or consistent with some kind of surgery or alteration ... now your's looks bout 7.5 x 6.6 midshaft to me, i bet you missed your measurements by a half inch or so, anyways, congrats on the genetic lottery there, but I'd say your girth is more consistent throughout the penis as you would expect because you don't have sickle cell anemia being that you're white lol ... still though, a virgin taking that without pain? lol very interesting

more like 7x6 but not 8x7 and not 7.5 x 6.6

my base girth is over 7 inches thick & 6.5mid.. your nowhere near 7 inches in girth


please spare me I'm tall or have big hands, big quads..

[PNS85 Member Find all posts View Profile Close PNS85]

more like 7x6 but not 8x7 and not 7.5 x 6.6

my base girth is over 7 inches thick & 6.5mid.. your nowhere near 7 inches in girth


please spare me I'm tall or have big hands, big quads..

Jeez guys... can this thread please stop being hijacked by people who don't believe my claims? For the umpteenth time, I'll post a video soon. At that point either I'll prove that my claimed stats are true or you'll all prove that I'm a lying asshole. Until then, can we please just focus on the topic I actually bring up here - women's opinion on girth limits? I really didn't create this thread to get in a flame war with a bunch of people who think I'm lying.

[BigO AdministratorPEGym Hero Find all posts View Profile Close BigO]

more like 7x6 but not 8x7 and not 7.5 x 6.6

my base girth is over 7 inches thick & 6.5mid.. your nowhere near 7 inches in girth


please spare me I'm tall or have big hands, big quads..

I don't usually comment on others size, you are both well endowed for sure but Thick_Unit, if your saying he is not 7 then I guarantee you there is not a snow balls chance in hell that your 7.anything at your base, unless of course your pulling the tape around a nut too.

The honest truth is that just about all "base girth" claims are complete bullshit, I think it is ridiculous to even measure base girth. It is as bad as guys that have a tape on a flaccid claiming 7 inches of flaccid length, yea, right. The dick is drooping down and the guys are measuring that. There is probably not a member here at the gym that can measure 6 or 7 inches flaccid with their dick straight out on a table, maybe 6. All of you all know who you are and many of you have posted in this thread, attacked a new guy who honestly is thicker ( looking ) than any one else that has posted in this thread.

One guy attacks and then says he is 7 point ( lolololololol )whatever at the base, show me the picture and I will tear it apart on the forums in front of everyone, where are the 7 inch flaccid guys, some of you post that rediculous bullshit and it is laughable, so are we going to play nice or am I going to find a bullshit claim on all of you and start my own thread on it, trust me. A few of you ( an ass ton) wont like it.

I was skeptical too, and I have since realized my actions were wrong, show me that 7.something base girth their big guy, I am waiting because so far I did not see a tape in your pics either.

if anyone has anything else negative to say say it elsewhere.

This is not only directed at you, Thick_unit, its just enough of this stuff already, he is clearly not here to lie or troll.

[PNS85 Member Find all posts View Profile Close PNS85]

Wow, thanks for defending me BigO!

Yes, I haven't uploaded any pics with a tape measure yet. I need to get one of the flexible ones first (which I recently learned is called a "tailor's tape"). Once I get one (and finish recovering from my poison oak) I'll record a video with measurements since people might still claim photoshopping took place in measurement pics. When that time comes, can someone inform me of the proper way to share videos on here? It looks like there's only an area to upload pictures, so should I upload the video to another site and then just post a link to it? If so, what site would you recommend?

Thanks.

Again, I'd still love it if more than one woman chimed in here regarding my questions in my OP. :-)

[NCGUY1972 Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close NCGUY1972]

The honest truth is that just about all "base girth" claims are complete bullshit, I think it is ridiculous to even measure base girth. .

in my case girth is tappered 3/4 so i do meaure base im trying to even out

[kickinthemebs Senior Member Member of the Month Feb 2014 Find all posts View Profile Close kickinthemebs]

Jeez, this poor guy seems genuine and he has been getting such stick on here. Fair enough 7 inch girth is extremely rare, but that doesn't mean it isn't out there. I haven't been looking at enough dicks or something because I can't tell if those dicks are 6, 6.5, or 7.

On another note, some members on here have claimed to get up to 8 inch girth from edging but nobody bats an eyelid because it was a mod...

[MySword Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close MySword]

in my case girth is tappered 3/4 so i do meaure base im trying to even out

Same here nc. It is hard to measure and I am careful with how far down I go (i have a good size turkey neck too...) But for me it is s guide meg is what I look closely at ..

[arkham Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close arkham]

Same here nc. It is hard to measure and I am careful with how far down I go (i have a good size turkey neck too...) But for me it is s guide meg is what I look closely at ..

Thats why I sterted measuring in 3 spots.

[Looking4more Retired Moderator Member of the Month Feb 2013PEGym Hero Find all posts View Profile Close Looking4more]

Welcome to the Gym PNS85.
I'm sorry you had to experience the nonsense that goes on around here sometimes. Try not to take it personally. They're just being the typical "I'm from Missouri" types and sometimes nothing short of taking your measurements themselves will satisfy some of them.
You have shown real class in the way you have dealt with the situation and I do commend you for that. If you stick around you will find that most here are very pleasant and also very supportive.

You may not get many more posts from the ladies here mostly because they probably haven't experienced girth like you have. The general consensus among the ladies is they like to feel filled up but not stretched beyond belief. While many women will be able to take your girth with a little work, many will also find it to be too much. My advice to you would be to do PE just for the sake of keeping your penis healthy. You don't need any more size to satisfy the ladies. You are already on the verge of being just too much for most.

Again, welcome to the Gym. Enjoy your stay here with us.

[NCGUY1972 Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close NCGUY1972]

Thats why I sterted measuring in 3 spots.

me too

[BigO AdministratorPEGym Hero Find all posts View Profile Close BigO]

in my case girth is tappered 3/4 so i do meaure base im trying to even out

I have seen your pictures, they are some of the best examples of how base girth should be measured.

[BigO AdministratorPEGym Hero Find all posts View Profile Close BigO]

Just to clear up my post earlier. My point was that we should not be guessing his size based off of our own.

I have seen Thick units pics and I was not accusing him of lying. Just pointing out that it does not feel good when someone says your not telling the truth. Many lie but many are telling the truth.

[PNS85 Member Find all posts View Profile Close PNS85]

Welcome to the Gym PNS85.
I'm sorry you had to experience the nonsense that goes on around here sometimes. Try not to take it personally. They're just being the typical "I'm from Missouri" types and sometimes nothing short of taking your measurements themselves will satisfy some of them.
You have shown real class in the way you have dealt with the situation and I do commend you for that. If you stick around you will find that most here are very pleasant and also very supportive.

Again, welcome to the Gym. Enjoy your stay here with us.

Thanks man, and don't worry. I expected some backlash when creating this thread so I was prepared for it.

You may not get many more posts from the ladies here mostly because they probably haven't experienced girth like you have. The general consensus among the ladies is they like to feel filled up but not stretched beyond belief. While many women will be able to take your girth with a little work, many will also find it to be too much. My advice to you would be to do PE just for the sake of keeping your penis healthy. You don't need any more size to satisfy the ladies. You are already on the verge of being just too much for most.

So, as I've said to a few other guys already... no offense, but you're still just one more guy telling me that I'm already on the verge of being too much for most women... however I have yet to hear this from an actual woman I've been with, or even a woman on this site or anywhere else. I'm certainly aware that I don't need any more size to satisfy the ladies... haha. Trying to get some gains from PE would be mainly to satisfy my own curiosity on the subject.

Consider this:

I haven't been looking at enough dicks or something because I can't tell if those dicks are 6, 6.5, or 7.

And this is coming from a guy who's a member at PEGym - probably much more familiar with eyeballing penis measurements than most guys. If a guy like that can't really tell, how do we expect women to be able to? My girlfriend even says that I only seem "slightly larger" than a couple of guys she's been with in the past. I really believe that even though my girth is pretty much a statistical anomaly it's never been perceived as such by women - they just seem to think I'm "large", period. And as I've said, even though there are plenty of guys out there with more length than me, my length has still caused far more issues than my girth in my sex life. It's my gut feeling that (if PE works for me) I could get up to 7.5" or 8" in girth without issue.

Let me stress again though that I really don't think the ladies feel that strongly one way or the other about girth as long as it's not too thin. I could probably satisfy my partner just the same with 5" of girth as I do now with 7", and I don't see why it would be any different if I gained more. If I experiment with trying to get gains from PE it would be purely for my own sake - not to try to "satisfy the ladies" more than I already do.

I guess you're right though, since very few women have experienced girth like mine it's unlikely that I'll get any real answers here. Even comparing women's opinions on girthy dildos evidently isn't relevant because several people have stated that women seem to find a penis easier to take than a dildo of the same girth.

So, pending any more responses from the ladies... do you guys have any ideas as to why everyone seems to think that my current girth is already too much for "most women" even though in my personal experience it hasn't felt that way at all?

[ThinJohnny Senior Member Find all posts View Profile Close ThinJohnny]

So, pending any more responses from the ladies... do you guys have any ideas as to why everyone seems to think that my current girth is already too much for "most women" even though in my personal experience it hasn't felt that way at all?

I honestly don't think you're going to find your answer here, because "most women" are not here, and all the guys so far are mystified.

You could try a size queeen site. You'll definitely find more people willing to talk about it with you there, although they don't represent most women either.

You have to remember, there are only a handful of women here, and a lot of the guys on this site(myself included) are insecure about their girth. They're not going to want to spend lots of time ruminating over the mystery of why girls love your huge girth and don't hate it, like they had hoped they would.

I hope you understand that I'm not attacking you here, PNS85, or trying to be rude. I'm just being honest. I think you're beating a dead horse:-) No pun intended.

Personally, I think the only way to get your answer is to have sex with a lot more women.

For what it's worth, I'll attempt to answer your question. I think there are only a few possibilities:

1)All the other guys here with big girth are lying, to make all of us smaller guys feel better.

2)The women you have been with all happened to be freaks of nature when it comes to handling girth.

3)You managed to get them more aroused before entering, through a combination of a deep emotional connection and the sheer turn on caused by the sight of the monster.

I think the reason you've gotten so much backlash is that none of these seem likely at all, especially when there's a virgin in the mix.

I belive it's number two, as unlikely as it seems.

I think you believe it's number 3, and you want the women here to tell you that. Nothing wrong with that, by the way. I'm just psychoanalyzing you. And not to piss you off, either, but to explain the backlash. If I was thinking it, others may have been thinking it, too.

Hopefully you won't take this personally, and the mods will have mercy on me:-)

Good luck with your PE'ing, but I wouldn't touch that thing. Why risk injury.